Two weeks ago, Keisha Sean Waites made history by winning Georgia’s race for insurance commissioner. Now she’s already facing pushback.

According to the former Atlanta City Council member and veteran FEMA emergency management official, insurance companies, trade groups and their lobbyists are targeting the reform policies she campaigned on that would lower costs for many Black Georgians.

“There are a number of individuals that are concerned, frightened, cautious,” Waites told Capital B Atlanta. “They are following my statements very closely.”

Waites, one of eight Black women Democrats elected to statewide offices, defeated Republican incumbent Insurance Commissioner John King in the midterms. She campaigned on lowering insurance prices for cost-burdened Georgians, many of whom are Black.

One of her policy proposals would make it illegal for auto insurers to calculate rates based on a customer’s credit score or residential ZIP code. These practices have caused policyholders in majority-Black neighborhoods to pay as much as 15% more on their premiums than those who live in majority-white regions, according to a 2024 consumer analysis.

The day after Waites won the election, Insurance Journal, an industry trade publication, reported that property and casualty insurance providers in Georgia are “bracing for new scrutiny” and limits.

Georgia has the fourth-highest auto insurance rates in the nation, according to an Insurify analysis reported by Kiplinger.com. Atlanta had the fourth-highest correlation in the nation between higher premiums and non-white ZIP codes last year.

Michigan and California are among the states that already ban or strictly regulate insurance companies’ ability to charge more based on where people live.

“The Black community is disproportionately impacted by this conversation,” Waites said. “I made that the backbone of my platform, and I’m not going to run away from that.”

While she plans to advocate in support of related bills backed by Democrats during the next legislative session, she also wants to have a cooperative relationship with insurance companies.

“I do want to clarify that I do want to work with the insurance industry,” she said. “I don’t want to take any steps, make any moves that will agitate the market.”

The Atlanta native also expressed pride in becoming the state’s first Black insurance commissioner, but stressed that she plans to be an advocate for all Georgians.

She noted the coalition of Georgians — Black, white and brown, male and female, Republican and Democrat — who supported her campaign in November.

“We had broad support,” Waited said. “For that reason, we will make sure to be an advocate for all of Georgia.”

Read More: 

Chauncey Alcorn is Capital B Atlanta's state and local politics reporter.